Judge · mostly Ultimate Fighting Championship

Dave Tirelli

363 scorecards 363 decisions 2010–2026

All judges →Robberies →

Odd one out 6.9% the room: 6.5%

363cards

67splits · 18%

25times the odd one out

86%with the media · 201 fights

71%with the fans · 157 fights

3.2%10-8 rounds

By year

Cards per year; the darker part is the times they were the odd one out

Disputed cards

Where the other judges or the media had it the other way, newest first

23 Aug 2025 Su Young You def. Long Xiao Unanimous · Bantamweight · UFC Fight Night 257: Walker vs. Zhang 29-28 for Su Young You media 2–4 fans 4070% against
12 Jul 2025 Gabriel Bonfim def. Stephen Thompson Split · Welterweight · UFC on ESPN 70: Lewis vs. Teixeira 29-28 for Gabriel Bonfim split media 2–12 fans 920% against
23 Aug 2024 Timur Khizriev def. Gabriel Braga Split · Featherweight · PFL 9: 2024 Playoffs 29-28 for Gabriel Braga odd one out fans 2500% against
23 Aug 2024 Brendan Loughnane def. Kai Kamaka III Split · Featherweight · PFL 9: 2024 Playoffs 29-28 for Kai Kamaka III odd one out media 5–1 fans 2500% against
1 Jun 2024 André Lima def. Mitch Raposo Split · Flyweight · UFC 302: Makhachev vs. Poirier 29-28 for Mitch Raposo odd one out media 14–0 fans 440% against
1 Jun 2024 Sean Strickland def. Paulo Costa Split · Middleweight · UFC 302: Makhachev vs. Poirier 49-46 for Paulo Costa odd one out media 24–0 fans 280% against
4 Nov 2023 Marc Diakiese def. Kauê Fernandes Split · Lightweight · UFC Fight Night 231: Almeida vs. Lewis 29-28 for Kauê Fernandes odd one out media 12–1 fans 1670% against
3 Dec 2022 Clay Guida def. Scott Holtzman Split · Lightweight · UFC on ESPN 42: Thompson vs. Holland 29-28 for Scott Holtzman odd one out media 17–0 fans 2090% against
25 Nov 2022 Aspen Ladd def. Julia Budd Split · Featherweight · PFL 10: 2022 Championships 29-28 for Aspen Ladd split media 2–5 fans 4710% against
13 Aug 2021 Pam Sorenson def. Roberta Paim Samad Split · Featherweight · Bellator 264: Mousasi vs. Salter 29-28 for Roberta Paim Samad odd one out fans 4290% against
25 Jun 2021 Mariana Morais def. Kaitlin Young Split · Lightweight · PFL 2021 #6: Regular Season 29-28 for Kaitlin Young odd one out
11 Jun 2021 Justin Gonzales def. Ty-wan Claxton Split · Featherweight · Bellator 260: Lima vs. Amosov 29-28 for Ty-wan Claxton odd one out fans 0% with
11 Jun 2021 Bobby King def. Nick Newell Split · Lightweight · Bellator 260: Lima vs. Amosov 29-28 for Nick Newell odd one out fans 6670% with
12 Nov 2020 Yaroslav Amosov def. Logan Storley Split · Welterweight · Bellator 252: Pitbull vs. Carvalho 29-28 for Logan Storley odd one out media 6–1 fans 2080% against
26 Sep 2020 Hakeem Dawodu def. Zubaira Tukhugov Split · Featherweight · UFC 253: Adesanya vs. Costa 29-28 for Zubaira Tukhugov odd one out media 7–13 fans 3880% against
24 Jul 2020 Jay Jay Wilson def. Ty-wan Claxton Split · Featherweight · Bellator 242: Bandejas vs. Pettis 30-27 for Jay Jay Wilson split media 2–3 fans 4290% against
16 May 2020 Yadong Song def. Marlon Vera Unanimous · Featherweight · UFC on ESPN 8: Overeem vs. Harris 29-28 for Yadong Song media 8–9 fans 3890% against
16 May 2020 Cláudia Gadelha def. Angela Hill Split · Strawweight · UFC on ESPN 8: Overeem vs. Harris 29-28 for Cláudia Gadelha split media 4–13 fans 2340% against
13 May 2020 Ricky Simón def. Ray Borg Split · Bantamweight · UFC Fight Night 171: Smith vs. Teixeira 29-28 for Ray Borg odd one out media 16–0 fans 820% against
9 May 2020 Carla Esparza def. Michelle Waterson-Gomez Split · Strawweight · UFC 249: Ferguson vs. Gaethje 30-27 for Michelle Waterson-Gomez odd one out media 8–9 fans 5600% with
9 May 2020 Anthony Pettis def. Donald Cerrone Unanimous · Welterweight · UFC 249: Ferguson vs. Gaethje 29-28 for Anthony Pettis media 6–7 fans 3280% against
23 Nov 2019 Fabian Edwards def. Mike Shipman Split · Middleweight · Bellator London - MVP vs. Melillo 29-28 for Mike Shipman odd one out fans 8260% with
2 Nov 2019 Darren Till def. Kelvin Gastelum Split · Middleweight · UFC 244: Masvidal vs. Diaz 30-27 for Kelvin Gastelum odd one out media 16–0 fans 810% against
26 Oct 2019 Manny Muro def. Nick Newell Split · Lightweight · Bellator 232: MacDonald vs. Lima 2 29-27 for Nick Newell odd one out media 4–1 fans 4550% with
25 Oct 2019 Ed Ruth def. Jason Jackson Split · Welterweight · Bellator 231: Mir vs. Nelson 2 29-28 for Ed Ruth split media 2–4 fans 4000% against
18 Oct 2019 Darren Stewart def. Deron Winn Split · Middleweight · UFC on ESPN 6: Reyes vs. Weidman 29-28 for Deron Winn odd one out media 6–6 fans 3700% against
4 May 2019 Arjan Bhullar def. Juan Adams Unanimous · Heavyweight · UFC Fight Night 151: Iaquinta vs. Cowboy 30-27 for Arjan Bhullar media 4–8 fans 2970% against
30 Mar 2019 Kevin Holland def. Gerald Meerschaert Split · Middleweight · UFC on ESPN 2: Barboza vs. Gaethje 29-28 for Gerald Meerschaert odd one out media 3–14 fans 5780% with
15 Feb 2019 Matt Probin def. Ali Zebian Split · Featherweight · Bellator 215: Mitrione vs. Kharitonov 29-28 for Ali Zebian odd one out
20 Jan 2018 Gian Villante def. Francimar Barroso Split · Light Heavyweight · UFC 220: Miocic vs. Ngannou 29-28 for Francimar Barroso odd one out media 17–0 fans 550% against
28 Oct 2017 Deiveson Figueiredo def. Jarred Brooks Split · Flyweight · UFC Fight Night 119: Brunson vs. Machida 29-28 for Deiveson Figueiredo split media 6–8 fans 3190% against
5 Aug 2017 Alexa Grasso def. Randa Markos Split · Strawweight · UFC Fight Night 114: Pettis vs. Moreno 29-28 for Randa Markos odd one out media 15–3 fans 4700% with
22 Jul 2017 Darren Elkins def. Dennis Bermudez Split · Featherweight · UFC on Fox 25: Weidman vs. Gastelum 29-28 for Darren Elkins split media 7–9 fans 4520% against
8 Apr 2017 Des Green def. Josh Emmett Split · Lightweight · UFC 210: Cormier vs. Johnson 2 29-28 for Josh Emmett odd one out media 15–1 fans 1870% against
18 Mar 2017 Steven Rodriguez def. Alexandre de Almeida Split · Featherweight · WSOF 35: Ivanov vs. Jordan 29-28 for Alexandre de Almeida odd one out fans 0% with
22 Apr 2016 Brent Primus def. Gleristone Santos Split · Lightweight · Bellator 153: Koreshkov vs. Henderson 29-28 for Brent Primus split media 1–6 fans 620% against
17 Oct 2015 Bruce Boyington def. Rodrigo Almeida Split · Featherweight · WSOF 24: Fitch vs. Okami 29-28 for Bruce Boyington split media 2–4 fans 3330% against
4 Apr 2015 Liz Carmouche def. Lauren Murphy Unanimous · Bantamweight · UFC Fight Night 63: Mendes vs. Lamas 29-28 for Liz Carmouche media 3–10 fans 940% against
4 Apr 2015 Al Iaquinta def. Jorge Masvidal Split · Lightweight · UFC Fight Night 63: Mendes vs. Lamas 29-28 for Al Iaquinta split media 2–12 fans 1820% against
28 Feb 2014 Matt Bessette def. Diego Nunes Split · Featherweight · Bellator 110: Rampage vs. M'Pumbu 30-27 for Matt Bessette split media 0–7 fans 380% against

Latest cards

The newest 60 of 363