Judge · mostly Cage Warriors

David Lethaby

600 scorecards 600 decisions 2013–2026

All judges →Robberies →

Odd one out 4.5% the room: 6.5%

600cards

79splits · 13%

27times the odd one out

94%with the media · 188 fights

76%with the fans · 191 fights

6.4%10-8 rounds

By year

Cards per year; the darker part is the times they were the odd one out

Disputed cards

Where the other judges or the media had it the other way, newest first

24 Jan 2026 Natália Silva def. Rose Namajunas Unanimous · Flyweight · UFC 324: Gaethje vs. Pimblett 29-28 for Natália Silva media 5–13 fans 2780% against
4 Oct 2025 Claudio Iancu def. Kevin Caperna Split · Bantamweight · Cage Warriors 195: Rome 29-28 for Kevin Caperna odd one out fans 10000% with
12 Jul 2025 Shajidul Haque def. Jawany Scott Split · Flyweight · title · Cage Warriors 192: London 48-46 for Jawany Scott odd one out
15 Mar 2025 Joe Fields def. Enrico Di Gangi Split · Flyweight · Cage Warriors 185: Manchester 29-28 for Enrico Di Gangi odd one out fans 10000% with
8 Mar 2025 Mairon Santos def. Francis Marshall Split · Featherweight · UFC 313: Pereira vs. Ankalaev 29-28 for Mairon Santos split media 0–13 fans 1230% against
26 Oct 2024 Rinat Fakhretdinov def. Carlos Leal Unanimous · Welterweight · UFC 308: Topuria vs. Holloway 29-28 for Rinat Fakhretdinov media 0–16 fans 830% against
14 Sep 2024 Simeon Powell def. Rafael Xavier Split · Light Heavyweight · Bellator Champions Series: London 29-28 for Rafael Xavier odd one out fans 10000% with
22 Jun 2024 Rinat Fakhretdinov def. Nicolas Dalby Split · Welterweight · UFC on ABC 6: Whittaker vs. Aliskerov 29-28 for Rinat Fakhretdinov split media 6–7 fans 2340% against
15 Mar 2024 Jack Claffey def. Marko Sarasjärvi Split · Featherweight · Cage Warriors 167: Unplugged 29-28 for Marko Sarasjärvi odd one out
9 Sep 2023 Jamie Mullarkey def. John Makdessi Unanimous · Lightweight · UFC 293: Adesanya vs. Strickland 29-28 for Jamie Mullarkey media 2–12 fans 1140% against
3 Jun 2023 Leo Brichta def. Maciej Kazieczko Split · Lightweight · KSW 83: Colosseum 2 29-28 for Maciej Kazieczko odd one out fans 2000% against
4 Mar 2023 Mateusz Gamrot def. Jalin Turner Split · Lightweight · UFC 285: Jones vs. Gane 29-28 for Jalin Turner odd one out media 23–3 fans 3550% against
20 Nov 2022 Morgan Charrière def. Daniel Bažant Split · Featherweight · Cage Warriors 147: Unplugged 29-28 for Daniel Bažant odd one out fans 2670% against
22 Oct 2022 Sean O'Malley def. Petr Yan Split · Bantamweight · UFC 280: Oliveira vs. Makhachev 29-28 for Sean O'Malley split media 1–25 fans 2480% against
20 Aug 2022 Stuart Austin def. Sofiane Boukichou Split · Heavyweight · PFL 9: 2022 Playoffs 29-28 for Sofiane Boukichou odd one out fans 0% with
13 Aug 2022 Chris Mixan def. Christian Stigenberg Split · Welterweight · PFL 8: 2022 Playoffs 29-28 for Christian Stigenberg odd one out fans 6250% with
11 Jun 2022 Valentina Shevchenko def. Taila Santos Split · Flyweight · title · UFC 275: Teixeira vs. Procházka 48-47 for Taila Santos odd one out media 19–8 fans 4390% against
13 May 2022 Logan Storley def. Michael Page Split · Welterweight · title · Bellator 281: MVP vs. Storley 48-47 for Michael Page odd one out media 3–5 fans 4450% against
1 Oct 2021 James Sheehan def. Omiel Brown Split · Welterweight · Cage Warriors 128 29-28 for Omiel Brown odd one out fans 10000% with
19 Mar 2021 Agy Sardari def. Donovan Desmae Split · Lightweight · title · Cage Warriors 121: Sardari vs. Desmae 48-47 for Donovan Desmae odd one out fans 5000% with
17 Oct 2020 Guram Kutateladze def. Mateusz Gamrot Split · Lightweight · UFC Fight Night 180: Ortega vs. Korean Zombie 29-28 for Mateusz Gamrot odd one out media 14–3 fans 6440% with
15 Jul 2020 Tim Elliott def. Ryan Benoit Unanimous · Flyweight · UFC on ESPN 13: Kattar vs. Ige 29-28 for Tim Elliott media 6–12 fans 4290% against
11 Jul 2020 Muslim Salikhov def. Elizeu Zaleski Split · Welterweight · UFC 251: Usman vs. Masvidal 29-28 for Elizeu Zaleski odd one out media 2–14 fans 7940% with
11 Jul 2020 Alexander Volkanovski def. Max Holloway Split · Featherweight · title · UFC 251: Usman vs. Masvidal 48-47 for Max Holloway odd one out media 9–18 fans 5880% with
22 Feb 2020 Dan Hooker def. Paul Felder Split · Lightweight · UFC Fight Night 168: Felder vs. Hooker 48-47 for Dan Hooker split media 4–12 fans 3360% against
14 Sep 2019 Norman Parke def. Marcin Wrzosek Split · Lightweight · title · KSW 50: London 48-47 for Marcin Wrzosek odd one out fans 1880% against
7 Sep 2019 Paul Felder def. Edson Barboza Split · Lightweight · UFC 242: Khabib vs. Poirier 29-28 for Paul Felder split media 3–13 fans 3140% against
29 Jun 2019 Morgan Charrière def. Lewis Monarch Split · Featherweight · Cage Warriors 106: Night of Champions 29-28 for Lewis Monarch odd one out fans 0% with
16 Feb 2019 Madars Fleminas def. Matthew Bonner Split · Welterweight · Cage Warriors 101 29-28 for Matthew Bonner odd one out
20 Oct 2018 Ross Houston def. Stefano Paternò Split · Welterweight · title · Cage Warriors 98 48-46 for Stefano Paternò odd one out fans 4290% with
15 Sep 2018 Rustam Khabilov def. Kajan Johnson Split · Lightweight · UFC Fight Night 136: Hunt vs. Oleynik 29-28 for Kajan Johnson odd one out media 1–12 fans 9140% with
4 Mar 2017 Arnold Quero def. Joe McColgan Split · Lightweight · Cage Warriors Fighting Championship 81 29-28 for Joe McColgan odd one out fans 6670% with
1 Nov 2014 Ian Malone def. Mark Connor Split · Flyweight · Cage Warriors Fighting Championship 73 29-28 for Mark Connor odd one out
1 Mar 2014 Catherine Costigan def. Irene Cabello Split · Atomweight · Cage Warriors Fighting Championship 65 29-28 for Irene Cabello odd one out
25 Oct 2013 Ryan Roddy def. Fernando Gonzalez Split · Lightweight · CWFC - Fight Night 9 29-28 for Fernando Gonzalez odd one out fans 0% with
5 Oct 2013 Aaron Blackwell def. Kris Edwards Split · Bantamweight · Cage Warriors Fighting Championship 60 29-28 for Kris Edwards odd one out fans 0% with

Latest cards

The newest 60 of 600