Result Extreme Challenge 63 · Sat 23 Jul 2005 · Extreme Challenge

Ed Herman vs Dave Menne

Elo
77%23%

Tale of the tape

The better of each pair is lit
Ed HermanDave Menne
1,603 Elo 1,393
1,180 KO rating 1,046
1,281 Sub rating 1,273
1,266 Dec rating 1,069
Wins by
2 KO/TKO 7
7 Submission 15
1 Decision 18
Losses by
0 KO/TKO 4
3 Submission 1
0 Decision 6

Prices

The closing prices; the outcome that happened is outlined
Ed HermanDave Menne
-- Moneyline --

What the betting model makes of it

At the prices above

The model has no priced opinion on this bout.

Fight history

Every bout either man has on record, newest first. This one is marked; the rows above it came afterwards and were not known on the night. Amateur bouts are shaded. Blank means we hold no figure, not zero.

Ed Herman 10-3 going in · 20 bouts on record before this one Full profile →
#DateResultOpponent MethodRoundAge Elo Opp Elo Close Weight classEvent
50 2023-04-15 L Zak Cummings KO/TKOCombination Punches R314:13 42.5 1,628-61 1,738 +195 Light Heavyweight UFC on ESPN 44: Holloway vs. Allen Ultimate Fighting Championship
49 2021-08-07 L Alonzo Menifield DecisionUnanimous R315:00 40.8 1,758-108 1,676 +205 Light Heavyweight UFC 265: Lewis vs. Gane Ultimate Fighting Championship
48 2020-09-12 W Mike Rodriguez SubKimura R312:41 39.9 1,712+46 1,532 +195 Light Heavyweight UFC Fight Night 177: Waterson vs. Hill Ultimate Fighting Championship
47 2019-11-09 W Khadis Ibragimov DecisionUnanimous R315:00 39.1 1,668+44 1,524 +142 Light Heavyweight UFC Fight Night 163: Magomedsharipov vs. Kattar Ultimate Fighting Championship
46 2019-05-18 W Patrick Cummins KO/TKOKnee & Punches R13:39 38.6 1,600+69 1,525 +198 Light Heavyweight UFC Fight Night 152: Dos Anjos vs. Lee Ultimate Fighting Championship
45 2018-10-27 L Gian Villante DecisionSplit R315:00 38.1 1,577+22 1,693 +203 Light Heavyweight UFC Fight Night 138: Oezdemir vs. Smith Ultimate Fighting Championship
44 2017-07-07 L C.B. Dollaway DecisionUnanimous R315:00 36.8 1,613-26 1,652 +148 Light Heavyweight UFC: The Ultimate Fighter 25 Finale Ultimate Fighting Championship
43 2016-07-30 L Nikita Krylov KO/TKOHead Kick R25:40 35.8 1,673-60 1,786 +180 Light Heavyweight UFC 201: Lawler vs. Woodley Ultimate Fighting Championship
42 2016-01-17 W Tim Boetsch KO/TKOKnee & Punches R26:39 35.3 1,573+100 1,623 +192 Light Heavyweight UFC Fight Night 81: Dillashaw vs. Cruz Ultimate Fighting Championship
41 2015-01-31 L Derek Brunson KO/TKOPunches R10:36 34.3 1,646-74 1,702 +347 Middleweight UFC 183: Silva vs. Diaz Ultimate Fighting Championship
40 2014-05-10 W Rafael Natal DecisionUnanimous R315:00 33.6 1,641+6 1,659 +105 Middleweight UFC Fight Night 40: Brown vs. Silva Ultimate Fighting Championship
39 2013-11-16 L Thales Leites DecisionUnanimous R315:00 33.1 1,688-47 1,812 +179 Middleweight UFC 167: St. Pierre vs. Hendricks Ultimate Fighting Championship
38 2013-07-27 W Trevor Smith DecisionSplit R315:00 32.8 1,674+14 1,530 -260 Middleweight UFC on Fox 8: Johnson vs. Moraga Ultimate Fighting Championship
37 2013-01-12 L Ronaldo Souza SubKimura R13:10 32.3 1,714-40 1,923 +284 Middleweight Strikeforce: Marquardt vs. Saffiedine Strikeforce
36 2012-08-11 NC Jake Shields Decision R315:00 31.9 1,805-91 1,792 +167 Middleweight UFC 150: Henderson vs. Edgar 2 Ultimate Fighting Championship
35 2012-02-04 W Clifford Starks SubRear Naked Choke R26:43 31.3 1,760+45 1,577 -302 Middleweight UFC 143: Diaz vs. Condit Ultimate Fighting Championship
34 2011-08-14 W Kyle Noke SubKneebar R14:15 30.9 1,651+109 1,738 -- Middleweight UFC Live 5: Hardy vs. Lytle Ultimate Fighting Championship
33 2011-06-04 W Tim Credeur KO/TKOPunches R10:48 30.7 1,546+104 1,614 -- Middleweight UFC: The Ultimate Fighter 13 Finale Ultimate Fighting Championship
32 2009-08-29 L Aaron Simpson KO/TKOKnee Injury R25:17 28.9 1,703-135 1,491 -- Middleweight UFC 102: Couture vs. Nogueira Ultimate Fighting Championship
31 2009-04-18 W David Loiseau DecisionUnanimous R315:00 28.5 1,593+110 1,683 -- Middleweight UFC 97: Redemption Ultimate Fighting Championship
30 2008-09-17 L Alan Belcher DecisionSplit R315:00 28.0 1,616-22 1,520 -- Middleweight UFC Fight Night 15: Diaz vs. Neer Ultimate Fighting Championship
29 2008-04-19 L Demian Maia SubTriangle Choke R27:27 27.5 1,728-112 1,626 -- Middleweight UFC 83: Serra vs. St. Pierre 2 Ultimate Fighting Championship
28 2007-11-17 W Joe Doerksen KO/TKOPunch R310:39 27.1 1,629+99 1,674 -- Middleweight UFC 78: Validation Ultimate Fighting Championship
27 2007-06-16 W Scott Smith SubRear Naked Choke R27:25 26.7 1,570+59 1,454 -- Middleweight UFC 72: Victory Ultimate Fighting Championship
26 2007-01-25 W Chris Price SubArmbar R12:58 26.3 1,521+49 1,357 -- Middleweight UFC Fight Night 8: Evans vs. Salmon Ultimate Fighting Championship
25 2006-10-10 L Jason MacDonald SubTriangle Choke R12:43 26.0 1,647-126 1,484 -- Middleweight UFC Fight Night 6.5: Ortiz vs. Shamrock 3 Ultimate Fighting Championship
24 2006-06-24 L Kendall Grove DecisionUnanimous R315:00 25.7 1,690-42 1,413 -- Middleweight UFC: The Ultimate Fighter 3 Finale Ultimate Fighting Championship
23 2006-02-22 W Rory Singer SubRear Naked Choke R27:31 25.4 1,652+38 1,429 -- Middleweight UFC - The Ultimate Fighter Season 3 Semifinals, Day 2 The Ultimate Fighter
22 2006-02-14 W Danny Abbadi SubArmbar R14:20 25.4 1,643+8 1,125 -- Middleweight UFC - The Ultimate Fighter Season 3 Quarterfinals, Day 7 The Ultimate Fighter
21 2005-07-23 W Dave Menne this fight KO/TKOGroin Injury R15:00 24.8 1,603+40 1,393 -- Middleweight Extreme Challenge 63 Extreme Challenge
20 2005-06-17 W Nick Thompson KO/TKOInjury R1 24.7 1,523+80 1,494 -- -- Hand 2 Hand Combat Ohio Regional
19 2005-04-30 W Rhomez Brower SubArmbar R12:47 24.6 1,511+12 1,053 -- Middleweight IFC 23: Mayhem In Montana International Fighting Championship
18 2005-03-26 W Glover Teixeira DecisionUnanimous R315:00 24.5 1,504+6 1,259 -- Open Weight SportFight 9: Respect SportFight
17 2004-10-23 L Joe Doerksen SubTriangle Choke R312:12 24.1 1,593-88 1,590 -- Middleweight SportFight 7: Frightnight SportFight
16 2004-08-28 W Brian Ebersole SubTriangle Choke R25:00 23.9 1,493+100 1,543 -- Middleweight SportFight 5: Stadium SportFight
15 2004-07-25 L Kazuo Misaki SubArm Triangle Choke R28:31 23.8 1,574-81 1,599 -- Middleweight Pancrase 137 Pancrase
14 2004-06-26 W Shane Davis SubArmbar R310:51 23.7 1,537+37 1,310 -- Middleweight SportFight 4: Fight For Freedom SportFight
13 2004-06-03 W Cory Devela SubArmbar R13:20 23.7 1,507+30 1,232 -- -- PFA - Pride and Fury Idaho Regional
12 2004-04-17 W Jacen Flynn SubArmbar R28:48 23.5 1,467+40 1,257 -- Open Weight SportFight 3: Dome SportFight
11 2004-04-03 W Justin Hawes SubArmbar R28:45 23.5 1,440+27 1,145 -- Middleweight Desert Brawl 10: Schultz vs. Gilardi Desert Brawl
10 2004-02-21 W Derek Downey KO/TKOPunches R312:14 23.4 1,335+104 1,403 -- Middleweight SportFight 1: Revolution SportFight
9 2004-01-03 W Rich Guerin SubKeylock R417:17 23.3 1,214+121 1,355 -- -- PPKA: Ultimate Fight Night 3 Pacific Pankration Kickboxing Association
8 2003-11-08 W Ryan Pope SubArmbar R10:24 23.1 1,141+73 1,181 -- Middleweight Desert Brawl 9: Hallman vs. Taylor Desert Brawl am
7 2003-08-23 L Shane Davis SubArmbar R12:18 22.9 1,253-112 1,154 -- -- SportFight: Second Coming SportFight
6 2003-06-07 W Nick Frazier KO/TKOPunches R11:05 22.7 1,218+35 1,042 -- -- FCFF - Rumble at the Roseland 8 Full Contact Fighting Federation am
5 2003-05-10 W Ryan Pope SubArmbar R12:38 22.6 1,175+43 1,049 -- -- Xtreme Ring Wars 2 Xtreme Ring Wars am
4 2003-04-19 W Jessi Ward SubSubmission R14:38 22.5 1,129+47 1,026 -- -- FCFF - Rumble at the Roseland 7 Full Contact Fighting Federation am
3 2003-02-28 L Andrew Taylor DecisionSplit R315:00 22.4 1,147-19 1,090 -- -- UFCF: Everett Extreme Challenge 7 United Full Contact Federation am
2 2002-11-09 W Byron Yates SubKimura R23:00 22.1 1,082+65 1,079 -- -- UFCF: Everett Extreme Challenge 6 United Full Contact Federation am
1 2002-10-05 W Noel Tworek KO/TKOPunches R1 22.0 1,017+66 1,017 -- -- FCFF: Fight Night 2 Full Contact Fighting Federation am
Dave Menne 40-11-2 going in · 53 bouts on record before this one Full profile →
#DateResultOpponent MethodRoundAge Elo Opp Elo Close Weight classEvent
64 2012-03-31 L Murilo Bustamante DecisionUnanimous R315:00 37.7 1,506-73 1,454 -- Middleweight Amazon Forest Combat 2 Amazon Forest Combat
63 2011-11-26 W Eric Davila SubGuillotine Choke R11:35 37.3 1,359+147 1,644 -- Welterweight UWF 1: Huerta vs. War Machine Ultimate Warrior Fighting MMA
62 2010-04-24 W Adrian Miles DecisionUnanimous R315:00 35.7 1,335+35 1,236 -- -- CFX / XKL - Mayhem in Minneapolis Cage Fighting Xtreme
61 2009-05-15 L Omar de la Cruz KO/TKOPunches R13:19 34.8 1,431-96 1,396 -- Welterweight Bellator 7 Bellator MMA
60 2009-04-17 W Norman Paraisy SubRear Naked Choke R312:39 34.7 1,383+48 1,215 -- Welterweight Bellator 3 & 4 Bellator MMA
59 2008-05-02 W Travis McCullough KO/TKOPunches R12:30 33.8 1,308+75 1,259 -- -- Brutaal - Fight Night Brutaal Genesis MMA
58 2006-12-13 L Luigi Fioravanti KO/TKOPunches R14:44 32.4 1,353-39 1,570 -- Welterweight UFC Fight Night 7: Sanchez vs. Riggs Ultimate Fighting Championship
57 2006-06-28 L Josh Koscheck DecisionUnanimous R315:00 31.9 1,382-29 1,583 -- Welterweight UFC Fight Night 5: Leben vs. Silva Ultimate Fighting Championship
56 2006-04-22 W Alex Reid DecisionUnanimous R315:00 31.7 1,329+53 1,303 -- -- Cage Rage 16: Critical Condition Cage Rage
55 2006-01-20 L Jake Shields DecisionUnanimous R315:00 31.5 1,353-24 1,503 -- Welterweight Rumble on the Rock 8 Rumble on the Rock
54 2005-07-23 L Ed Herman this fight KO/TKOGroin Injury R15:00 31.0 1,393-40 1,603 -- Middleweight Extreme Challenge 63 Extreme Challenge
53 2005-06-18 W Jerry Spiegel SubGuillotine Choke R13:17 30.9 1,371+22 1,033 -- -- Extreme Challenge 62 Extreme Challenge
52 2004-11-12 W Trevor Garrett DecisionSplit R315:00 30.3 1,420-49 1,128 -- -- Extreme Challenge 60 Extreme Challenge
51 2004-09-24 W Eddie Sanchez SubRear-Naked Choke R10:53 30.2 1,392+28 1,106 -- -- Extreme Challenge 59 Extreme Challenge
50 2004-06-11 W Todd Carney DecisionUnanimous R315:00 29.9 1,368+24 1,217 -- -- Extreme Challenge 58 Extreme Challenge
49 2004-03-26 W Leo Sylvest SubToe Hold R12:06 29.7 1,324+45 1,137 -- Middleweight Extreme Challenge 56 Extreme Challenge
48 2004-02-07 L Falaniko Vitale DecisionUnanimous R315:00 29.5 1,367-44 1,432 -- Middleweight SB 33: SuperBrawl 33 Icon Sport
47 2003-08-02 W Sam Cleveland KO/TKOPunches R1 29.0 1,346+22 1,007 -- -- EC - Best of the Best 2: Night Event Minnesota Regional
46 2003-06-25 L Hayato Sakurai KO/TKOCut R27:02 28.9 1,425-79 1,459 -- Welterweight Deep - 10th Impact DEEP
45 2003-06-14 W Dennis Reed KO/TKOTKO R1 28.9 1,399+26 1,095 -- -- Extreme Combat Minnesota Regional
44 2003-04-18 W Todd Carney SubGuillotine Choke R11:05 28.7 1,370+29 1,088 -- -- ICC 2: Rebellion Minnesota Regional
43 2002-09-27 L Phil Baroni KO/TKOPunches R10:18 28.2 1,486-116 1,369 -- Middleweight UFC 39: The Warriors Return Ultimate Fighting Championship
42 2002-07-30 W Robert Ferguson KO/TKORetirement R2 28.0 1,471+15 1,056 -- -- UAGF 2: Ultimate Cage Fighting 2 California Regional
41 2002-01-11 L Murilo Bustamante KO/TKOPunches R25:44 27.5 1,584-113 1,479 -- Middleweight UFC 35: Throwdown Ultimate Fighting Championship
40 2001-09-28 W Gil Castillo DecisionUnanimous R525:00 27.2 1,519+65 1,485 -- Middleweight UFC 33: Victory in Vegas Ultimate Fighting Championship
39 2001-02-24 L Hiromitsu Kanehara KO/TKOPunches R313:24 26.6 1,642-123 1,493 -- Heavyweight Rings - King of Kings 2000 Final Fighting Network RINGS
38 2001-02-08 W Shamil Magomedov DecisionUnanimous R110:00 26.5 1,641+1 1,062 -- Middleweight Shidokan Jitsu - Warriors War 1 Shidokan Jitsu
37 2001-02-08 W Karimula Barkalaev DecisionUnanimous R110:00 26.5 1,543+99 1,609 -- Middleweight Shidokan Jitsu - Warriors War 1 Shidokan Jitsu
36 2001-02-08 W Carlos Newton DecisionUnanimous R110:00 26.5 1,460+82 1,461 -- Middleweight Shidokan Jitsu - Warriors War 1 Shidokan Jitsu
35 2000-10-09 W Wataru Sakata DecisionUnanimous R210:00 26.2 1,423+37 1,244 -- Heavyweight Rings - King of Kings 2000 Block A Fighting Network RINGS
34 2000-10-09 W Roberto Traven DecisionUnanimous R315:00 26.2 1,377+47 1,325 -- Heavyweight Rings - King of Kings 2000 Block A Fighting Network RINGS
33 2000-07-22 L Chris Munsen DecisionUnanimous R210:00 26.0 1,528-151 1,115 -- Middleweight Rings USA - Rising Stars Block B Fighting Network RINGS
32 2000-06-15 D Ryuki Ueyama DecisionN/A R215:00 25.9 1,598-70 1,214 -- Middleweight Rings - Millennium Combine 2 Fighting Network RINGS
31 2000-05-13 W Jose Landi-Jons DecisionMajority R315:00 25.8 1,582+16 1,560 -- -- WEF 9: World Class World Extreme Fighting
30 2000-03-10 W Fabiano Iha DecisionUnanimous R315:00 25.6 1,605-22 1,159 -- Welterweight UFC 24: First Defense Ultimate Fighting Championship
29 1999-12-22 L Kiyoshi Tamura DecisionUnanimous R210:00 25.4 1,686-82 1,675 -- Heavyweight Rings - King of Kings 1999 Block B Fighting Network RINGS
28 1999-11-13 W LaVerne Clark SubGuillotine Choke R2 25.3 1,659+27 1,366 -- -- Extreme Challenge 29 Extreme Challenge
27 1999-11-13 W Chris Lytle DecisionUnanimous R210:00 25.3 1,646+13 1,307 -- -- Extreme Challenge 29 Extreme Challenge
26 1999-09-07 W Jutaro Nakao DecisionUnanimous R315:00 25.1 1,645+1 1,362 -- Middleweight SB 13: SuperBrawl 13 Icon Sport
25 1999-08-13 W Mark Walker SubRear-Naked Choke R11:15 25.0 1,637+8 1,116 -- -- Ultimate Wrestling Minnesota Regional
24 1999-07-04 W Joe Geromiller SubKneebar R13:10 24.9 1,629+7 1,088 -- -- Submission Fighting Championships 7 Illinois Regional
23 1999-06-19 W CJ Fernandes SubArmbar R10:58 24.9 1,617+13 1,172 -- Middleweight Dangerzone - Mahnomen Danger Zone
22 1999-06-11 W Brent Medley KO/TKO R10:21 24.9 1,593+23 1,267 -- -- Extreme Challenge 25 Extreme Challenge
21 1999-06-11 W Jesse Jones DecisionUnanimous R120:00 24.9 1,532+61 1,448 -- -- Extreme Challenge 25 Extreme Challenge
20 1999-05-29 W Dennis Hallman DecisionUnanimous R315:00 24.8 1,475+57 1,464 -- Middleweight Shooto - 10th Anniversary Event Shooto
19 1999-04-30 W Jim Czajkowski SubKneebar R1 24.8 1,410+65 1,320 -- -- Submission Fighting Championships 6 Illinois Regional
18 1999-04-02 W Ken Parham DecisionUnanimous R115:00 24.7 1,386+24 1,106 -- -- Extreme Challenge 23 Extreme Challenge
17 1999-04-02 W Mike McClure KO/TKOSubmission to Punches R14:47 24.7 1,337+49 1,172 -- -- Extreme Challenge 23 Extreme Challenge
16 1999-03-18 W Brett Jones SubRear-Naked Choke R10:14 24.6 1,310+27 1,017 -- -- Gladiators 2 Gladiators
15 1999-03-18 W Vernon Yates SubRear-Naked Choke R10:18 24.6 1,279+31 1,011 -- -- Gladiators 2 Gladiators
14 1998-10-17 W Adam Johnson KO/TKOGuillotine Choke R10:51 24.2 1,200+79 1,165 -- -- Extreme Challenge 21 Extreme Challenge
13 1998-10-17 L Matt Hughes DecisionUnanimous R115:00 24.2 1,326-126 1,134 -- -- Extreme Challenge 21 Extreme Challenge
12 1998-08-22 D Shonie Carter -- R120:00 24.1 1,307+20 1,386 -- -- Extreme Challenge 20 Extreme Challenge
11 1998-06-20 W Andy Sanders DecisionDecision R115:00 23.9 1,261+46 1,234 -- -- Extreme Challenge 19 Extreme Challenge
10 1998-06-20 W Phil Johns DecisionDecision R115:00 23.9 1,240+21 1,109 -- -- Extreme Challenge 19 Extreme Challenge
9 1998-05-30 W Henry Matamoros DecisionUnanimous R110:00 23.8 1,116+123 1,294 -- Welterweight GCF: Wisconsin Vale Tudo 2 Gladiators Cage Fighting
8 1998-04-04 L Adrian Serrano DecisionUnanimous R112:00 23.7 1,171-54 1,286 -- Welterweight Wisconsin Vale Tudo Gladiator Championship Fighting
7 1998-02-27 L Jesse Jones SubArmbar R15:45 23.6 1,235-64 1,331 -- Middleweight Extreme Challenge 15 Extreme Challenge
6 1997-04-18 W LaVerne Clark SubTriangle Choke R15:51 22.7 1,182+53 1,038 -- -- Extreme Challenge 5 Extreme Challenge
5 1997-04-18 L Shonie Carter DecisionSplit R115:00 22.7 1,232-51 1,060 -- -- Extreme Challenge 5 Extreme Challenge
4 1997-04-05 W Tim Wills SubPosition R11:06 22.7 1,201+31 934 -- -- HOOKnSHOOT - Absolute Fighting Championship 1 HOOKnSHOOT
3 1997-04-04 W Duane Bressinger SubArmbar R12:37 22.7 1,153+48 983 -- -- HOOKnSHOOT - Lightweight Championship HOOKnSHOOT
2 1997-04-04 W Adam Fisher SubRear-Naked Choke R13:39 22.7 1,087+66 1,000 -- -- HOOKnSHOOT - Lightweight Championship HOOKnSHOOT
1 1997-04-04 W Sean Coultas KO/TKO R13:29 22.7 1,000+88 1,000 -- -- HOOKnSHOOT - Lightweight Championship HOOKnSHOOT